Nigel Lythoe Tweets: SHOCKING American Idol News Tonight! (Who is Going Home?)

Nigel Lythgoe tweets, “#Spoiler Alert: Shocking #AmericanIdol news tonight!!!”

DISCUSS

My pick for elimination was one of the girls–probably Haley. But, if the news is A SHOCKING elimination, Legs Reinhart is probably safe.

Or, like some of you mentioned in comments, a fav lands in the bottom 3. Or perhaps it’s a lame joke about that stupid mansion ghost..

Maybe Nigel believes Naima would be a shocking boot after performing next to last and receiving lots of judge love? Personally, I would not find that shocking at all. She was a wild card pick and has been on the cusp. I’m not sure “America” is down with her reggae African-dancing self.

Or maybe it’s the judges pet, Lauren Alaina, who has already made an appearance in the bottom 3

Or maybe it’s a guy. Could Jacob Lusk or Stefano Langone be in the hot seat tonight?

I think Scotty McCreary, Casey Abrams, Paul McDonald, James Durbin, andPia Toscano.

Who the judges would save: Scotty, Casey, James. Pia, Jacob, Lauren.